Velour and Vellum

What Do Frankincense and Myrrh Smell Like? The Science and History of the Wise Men's Gifts

Frankincense smells bright, lemony and piney; myrrh is warm, bitter and balsamic. The chemistry, the 3,000-year trade and how to bring their mood home.

Frankincense smells bright, clean and resinous, with a lemony, pine-like lift and a faint peppery smoke; myrrh is darker, warmer and more bitter, closer to balsam, leather and damp earth. Together they make the scent most of us know simply as "church" or "incense", and the reason they smell so different from each other comes down to chemistry, geography and three thousand years of trade.

Every December the two resins reappear in carols, nativity scenes and gift boxes, yet few people have ever smelled them side by side. This is a guide to what they actually are, why they were once worth a fortune, and how to bring their mood into a home without filling it with smoke.

What are frankincense and myrrh, exactly?

Both are dried tree resins. When the bark of the tree is cut, it bleeds a milky sap that hardens in the air into translucent drops, which are scraped off and sorted by colour and size.

The harvest has barely changed in two thousand years. Writing in the first century, Pliny the Elder described collectors making an incision "where the bark appears to be fullest of juice", then waiting for the sap to harden into drops (Pliny, Natural History, Book 12).

Why do frankincense and myrrh smell so different?

Because they are built from different families of molecules.

Frankincense is dominated by light, quick-to-evaporate monoterpenes, above all alpha-pinene, the same molecule that gives pine and fir needles their sharp, fresh lift (we wrote about it in why Christmas trees smell so good). That is why a fresh piece of frankincense smells more like lemon peel and forest than like smoke.

The species matters, too. A 2012 chemical study comparing two frankincense trees long treated as one, Boswellia sacra from Oman and Yemen and Boswellia carterii from Somalia, found alpha-pinene averaged about 68% of the oil in the first and about 37% in the second, with the mirror-image forms of the molecule in strikingly different ratios (Journal of Chromatography A, via PubMed). In plain terms: two "frankincenses" can smell noticeably different, and a perfumer can tell them apart.

Myrrh is heavier. Its oil is rich in sesquiterpenes, larger molecules that evaporate slowly, including a group called furanosesquiterpenes that chemists use to identify true myrrh and tell it apart from related resins (Lund University research record). Slower molecules mean a deeper, longer-lasting, more bitter scent: the bass line to frankincense's melody.

FrankincenseMyrrh
TreeBoswelliaCommiphora
Colour of the resinPale yellow to milky greenRed-brown
First impressionLemony, piney, cleanWarm, bitter, balsamic
Behaves likeA top-to-heart noteA heart-to-base note
Pairs well withCitrus, white tea, cedarAmber, leather, rose, oud

Why were frankincense and myrrh once worth so much?

Because almost everyone wanted them and almost nobody could grow them. The most prized trees grow only in a narrow belt of southern Arabia and the Horn of Africa, so for centuries the resins travelled north by caravan and by sea to Egypt, Mesopotamia, the Mediterranean, India and China. UNESCO protects the frankincense trees of Wadi Dawkah, the caravan oasis of Shisr and the ancient ports of Khor Rori and Al-Baleed in Oman as the "Land of Frankincense" (UNESCO).

Rome was the greatest customer. Pliny complained that India, China and Arabia drained the empire of at least 100 million sesterces a year, and repeated the claim that the Emperor Nero burned more perfume at his wife Poppaea's funeral than Arabia produced in a year (Pliny, Book 12). Scent was smoke, and smoke was status: the word perfume itself goes back to the Latin per, "through", and fumare, "to smoke".

So when the Gospel of Matthew has the Magi bring gold, frankincense and myrrh, the audience would have understood all three as treasures fit for a king. Frankincense was burned in temples; myrrh was used in perfumed oils and in burial rites, which is why the trio is often read as a symbol as well as a gift.

Did you know? In the 15th century BCE, the Egyptian queen Hatshepsut sent an expedition to the land of Punt, on the Red Sea coast, and had it carved on the walls of her temple at Deir el-Bahari. The reliefs show her sailors carrying incense trees in baskets, "ready to plant", back to Egypt (PBS, Egypt's Golden Empire) — one of the earliest recorded attempts to move living trees from one country to another, all for the sake of a smell.

Is frankincense running out?

The honest answer is that wild supplies are under real pressure. A 2019 study in Nature Sustainability followed 23 Boswellia populations in Ethiopia, Eritrea and Sudan and found that 18 of them had almost no young trees coming up, because of grazing by cattle, goats and camels, fire and insect damage. The researchers projected that frankincense production from these trees could halve within about two decades (Wageningen University).

That does not mean the scent will vanish from our homes. It does mean that anyone who loves it has a reason to buy resin thoughtfully, and that perfumers increasingly build "incense" accords that capture the mood without relying entirely on the wild harvest.

What does "incense" mean on a fragrance label?

In perfumery, "incense" is usually an accord rather than a single ingredient: a composition designed to recall the air of a stone church after a service, cool, dry and faintly smoky. It may include frankincense, but the effect comes from the whole blend. "Myrrh" on a label, likewise, describes the warm, bitter-balsamic character of the note. If you are new to these words, perfumers place them in the amber and woody families, and Ambergris vs Amber explains the resinous "amber" they so often sit beside.

How do you bring frankincense and myrrh into a home?

Resinous scents are rich and slow, so a little goes a long way. A few tips we have learned:

  1. Smell them on their own first. If you can, crush a single drop of frankincense between two spoons and smell it before and after warming it in your hand. The citrus-pine top will surprise you; most people only know the smoke.
  2. Give them the evening rooms. Incense and myrrh suit a study, a library corner, a dining room or a bedroom more than a bright kitchen. They read as calm and contemplative, which is exactly why they were used in temples.
  3. Brighten frankincense, deepen myrrh. Frankincense sits beautifully next to citrus and white tea for a clean, airy room. Myrrh wants amber, leather, rose or oud for a darker, more enveloping one.
  4. Skip the smoke if you prefer. Burning resin on charcoal is the traditional route, but it fills a room with smoke and lingers on fabrics. A reed diffuser gives you the character of incense quietly and continuously, with no flame.
  5. Use fewer reeds in small rooms. Resinous blends project steadily. In a powder room or small bedroom, start with three or four reeds and add more only if you want a stronger presence.
  6. Store raw resin cool and sealed. The bright monoterpenes in frankincense are the first molecules to evaporate and oxidize, so keep resin in a closed jar away from sunlight and heat if you want it to keep its fresh top.
  7. Read the Latin. If you buy resin or essential oil, the species name tells you more than the word "frankincense": Boswellia sacra, carterii, papyrifera and serrata all smell different.
  8. Let the scent carry the season. Because these resins are so tied to December rituals, they work on memory as much as on the nose. We explored why in why smells trigger memories.

Quick answers

What does frankincense smell like? Fresh frankincense smells lemony, piney and clean, with a soft peppery smoke underneath. Burned, it becomes drier and more "church-like".

What does myrrh smell like? Myrrh smells warm, bitter and balsamic, with hints of leather and earth. It is darker and longer-lasting than frankincense.

Are frankincense and myrrh the same thing? No. Both are tree resins from southern Arabia and the Horn of Africa, but frankincense comes from Boswellia trees and myrrh from Commiphora trees, and they are made of different families of aroma molecules.

Why did the Wise Men bring frankincense and myrrh? In the ancient world both resins were precious trade goods, burned in temples and used in perfumed oils and burial rites, so they were gifts fit for a king and are often read as symbolic.

Can I get an incense scent at home without burning anything? Yes. A reed diffuser or a cold-air (nebulizing) scent system with an incense- or myrrh-led blend gives you the mood of incense with no flame and no smoke.

At Velour and Vellum, frankincense-and-myrrh season is when we reach most often for our darkest scent. If you'd like to try it at home, our Midnight Vellum reed diffuser, blended by hand in Toronto with notes of incense, myrrh and black amber, is the one we would recommend.

Explore: the Scaldera Arch · Shop the collection · Take the Scent Quiz · Membership · Refill subscription

More from the Journal