How Boutique Hotels and B&Bs Get Better Guest Reviews

How boutique hotels, inns and B&Bs earn better reviews: the arrival, room details, a signature scent, handwritten notes, asking within platform rules and responding well.

Guests rarely write reviews about a property. They write about moments: the welcome after a long drive, a bed they didn't want to leave, a host who remembered it was their anniversary, a shower that was lukewarm. For a boutique hotel, inn or B&B, better reviews come from designing those moments on purpose, fixing problems before checkout and asking every guest, fairly, to share their experience. Here is how independent properties do it.

Reviews are decided before guests arrive

The first impression starts with the confirmation email.

Send a warm pre-arrival message two or three days ahead with the practical details people actually need: parking, check-in time, the door code or who will greet them, and how to reach you.
Ask one simple question: "Is there anything that would make your stay easier, or are you celebrating anything?" The answers give you your best review material.
Be honest in your listing. Many disappointing reviews are about expectations, not quality. If the stairs are steep, the street is lively or the walls are old, say so. Guests forgive charm; they don't forgive surprises.
List accessibility details accurately so guests can plan. Ontario's customer service accessibility standard applies to organizations with one or more employees that serve the public, and the province's accessibility overview is a good place to start.

The arrival: the first ten minutes

Arrival sets the tone for the whole review.

Greet guests by name, at the door if you can.
Offer something immediately: a glass of water, tea, a seat. Travellers are tired.
Keep check-in short. Paperwork can wait; directions to the room, Wi-Fi and breakfast times cannot.
Make the entrance feel cared for: good light, no clutter, fresh flowers or greenery, and a clean, quiet scent.
Walk them to the room in a small property, and point out the two or three things that matter: how the heating works, where the extra blankets are, the best local coffee.

Our guide to improving the customer experience applies here as much as in any shop.

Room details guests write about

Sleep and cleanliness come up in review after review. Once a season, sleep in each of your rooms yourself and note everything that bothers you.

The bed: a good mattress, quality linens, a choice of pillows.
Darkness and quiet: blackout curtains or blinds, no glowing electronics, doors that close softly.
Temperature you can control, with instructions in plain words.
Water pressure and hot water that arrive quickly.
Outlets beside the bed for phones.
Lighting: a proper reading light on each side and a lamp that isn't the overhead.
The small luxuries: a kettle and good tea, a carafe of water, a robe, a full-length mirror.
Cleanliness in the corners: under the bed, the top of the door frame, the shower grout. Guests look.

A signature scent, used with care

Many hotels have a scent guests recognise the moment they walk in. For a small property it is a simple way to make the stay feel considered and memorable, and it ties together the entrance, the hallways and the shared rooms.

Scent the public spaces, not every room. The entrance, lobby, staircase and lounge are where scent does its work. Keep bedrooms lighter or unscented.
Offer fragrance-free rooms for guests who are sensitive or prefer none, and mention it in your listing.
Choose one scent and keep it. Consistency is what makes it recognisable, on the next visit and in the review: "The whole house smelled wonderful."
Choose flame-free and IFRA-compliant. Reed diffusers suit small spaces; a cold-air diffuser covers a larger lobby evenly.

Velour and Vellum's six scents are inspired by grand hotel lobbies, and properties that want the same scent in every space can see options on our scent for business page. For help choosing, read how to choose a signature scent for your business.

Handwritten notes and personal touches

Small gestures cost little and appear in reviews again and again, because they feel personal.

A handwritten welcome card in the room, with the guest's name: "Welcome, Sarah and Tom. We hope the drive was easy. Breakfast is from 8 to 10, and the café two doors down makes the best croissants in town. Enjoy your stay, Anna."
Acknowledge occasions you were told about: a card for an anniversary, a birthday treat at breakfast.
Remember returning guests. Note their room, their coffee, their dog's name.
Local knowledge, written down: a short, personal list of the places you actually recommend.

Fix problems before checkout

The most important review work happens during the stay, when you can still fix things.

Check in once, lightly, by text or in person on the first morning: "Is everything comfortable in the room? Anything we can bring you?"
Give staff permission to fix small problems on the spot, without asking a manager.
Treat a complaint as a gift. A guest who tells you about a noisy radiator at breakfast is giving you the chance to avoid reading about it online.

Ask for reviews, within the rules

Asking matters. A Cornell Center for Hospitality Research study found that simply encouraging guests to review was associated with better ratings relative to competitors (Hospitality Net, reporting on Cornell). But how you ask is regulated by the platforms and by law.

Ask every guest, not only the happy ones. Tripadvisor treats selectively asking only satisfied guests as fraud (Tripadvisor), and Google prohibits selectively soliciting positive reviews (Google). This practice is often called review gating.
No incentives. No discounts, upgrades or gifts in exchange for a review. Both platforms prohibit it.
Don't pressure guests on the premises. Google's policy says businesses should not require or pressure people to leave reviews while on site, or ask for specific content.
Staff and family don't review. Canada's Competition Bureau warns that businesses can be liable when employees post reviews without disclosing their connection (Competition Bureau). In the United States, the FTC's rule bans fake reviews, undisclosed insider reviews and incentives conditioned on a particular sentiment (FTC).
Booking platforms run their own review systems. Let them send their requests; you can add a friendly line in your thank-you email.

A fair thank-you script:

"Thank you for staying with us. If you have a moment, we'd be grateful for an honest review on Google or Tripadvisor. It helps other travellers find us, and it helps us keep improving. Safe travels."

More detail is in our guides to getting more Google reviews and 5-star reviews for short-term rental hosts.

Respond to reviews like a host

Responses are read by future guests as much as by the reviewer.

Prioritise thoughtful replies to critical reviews. The same Cornell research found ratings and revenue improved as response rates rose to about 40 percent, with diminishing returns beyond that, and recommended constructive responses to negative reviews over blanket thanks for positive ones (Hospitality Net).
Thank, acknowledge, explain what changed. "Thank you for telling us about the hot water on the third floor. We've had the boiler serviced and added a note to every room on how long it takes to warm up. We'd love to welcome you back."
Never argue, never share private details about a guest's stay, and never offer anything in exchange for changing or removing a review.
Reply to positive reviews specifically when you do: mention the thing they loved, by name.
Use the patterns. If three guests mention the same pillow, change the pillow.

Quick answers

How do small hotels get more positive reviews? Design a warm arrival, perfect the bed, darkness and hot water, add personal touches like handwritten notes, fix problems during the stay, and ask every guest for an honest review without incentives.

Can a hotel offer a discount for a review? No. Google and Tripadvisor both prohibit incentives for reviews, and asking only happy guests (review gating) is also prohibited.

How should a B&B respond to a bad review? Thank the guest, acknowledge the issue without arguing, explain what you changed and invite them back. Keep private details private.

Should a boutique hotel have a signature scent? It can help guests remember the stay. Scent the entrance and shared spaces lightly, keep bedrooms lighter or unscented, and offer fragrance-free rooms.

What do guests mention most in hotel reviews? Common themes include cleanliness, sleep quality, the welcome and the staff. Ask your own guests and read your reviews for patterns.

Where can I find a hotel-style scent for a small inn? Velour and Vellum blends hotel-inspired reed diffusers by hand in Toronto, and its Commercial Packages are organised by type of space, including lobbies and guest rooms.

Explore: the Scaldera Arch · Shop the collection · Take the Scent Quiz · Membership · Refill subscription