How to Spot Fake Reviews When Buying Home Fragrance

How to read home fragrance reviews with a clear eye, the red flags of fake or incentivized reviews, and what Canada's Competition Bureau and the US FTC say about them.

Reviews matter more for home fragrance than for almost anything else you buy online, because you can't smell through a screen. That is exactly what makes them a target. Here is how to read fragrance reviews with a clear eye, what Canadian and US rules say about fake reviews and testimonials, and the one promise we make about our own.

Why fragrance reviews are hard to read

Scent is personal and situational. The same reed diffuser can seem quiet in a tall, airy living room and generous in a small powder room. One person's "beautifully subtle" is another's "I can't smell it", and both can be completely honest. Seasons, airflow, where the diffuser sits and simply getting used to a scent all change the experience.

So when you read fragrance reviews, look for detail rather than stars. A careful review helps you picture the scent in your own space. A fake one rarely can, because the person writing it never lived with the product.

Signs a review is genuinely useful

Specifics about the space. Room size, where the diffuser sat, whether a window was open, how long they've had it.
Words about the scent itself. What it reminded them of, how it changed over time, what they'd compare it to.
Honest mixed feelings. "Lovely, but softer than I expected in a large room" is often more trustworthy than unbroken praise.
A real reviewer history. The US Federal Trade Commission suggests checking whether a reviewer has written other reviews; an account created only to review one product may be fake (FTC consumer advice).
Updates over time. A follow-up after weeks of use says more than a first impression.

Red flags for fake or incentivized reviews

A sudden burst of reviews in a short period. The FTC names this as a common sign that reviews may be fake (FTC consumer advice).
Generic superlatives. "Best product ever, amazing quality, fast shipping" could describe anything. If no one mentions what the fragrance actually smells like, be cautious.
Repeated phrasing. The same unusual words or sentence shapes across several "different" reviewers.
Details that don't match. A review praising a scent note, size or feature the product doesn't have.
Too-perfect scores. Hundreds of reviews and not one critical voice is unusual for something as personal as fragrance.
Disclosed incentives. "I received this free in exchange for my honest review" doesn't make a review fake, but it's context worth weighing. Some platforms show a label or badge on incentivized reviews.
Polished but empty text. The FTC's rule explicitly covers AI-generated fake reviews, so smooth writing is no guarantee that a real person used the product.
Fake negatives. Fake reviews aren't always glowing; the FTC notes that some negative reviews are posted to damage a competitor.

One honest caveat, from the FTC itself: "it can often be nearly impossible to tell for sure." Look at the overall pattern rather than judging any single review.

What the rules say in Canada

In Canada, fake reviews fall under the deceptive marketing provisions of the Competition Act.

False or misleading representations. Making "a representation to the public that is false or misleading in a material respect" to promote a product is reviewable conduct under section 74.01 (Competition Act).
Testimonials. Under section 74.02, a business that publishes a testimonial must be able to show the person actually gave it, or approved it in writing, and that it matches what they said (Competition Act).
Employee reviews. On 18 January 2024, the Competition Bureau warned that businesses could be liable when employees post reviews without disclosing their connection. Commissioner Matthew Boswell put it plainly: "When employees post reviews without disclosing their relationship with the business, consumers are misled." The Bureau urged businesses to train staff and put compliance programs in place, and encouraged Canadians to report suspected fake reviews (Competition Bureau, 2024).
A well-known precedent. In October 2015, Bell Canada agreed to a 1.25 million dollar administrative monetary penalty after employees posted positive app-store reviews without disclosing they worked there (Competition Bureau, 2015).
More recent changes. Amendments to the Competition Act in June 2024 strengthened the deceptive marketing rules, and from 20 June 2025 private parties can bring deceptive marketing cases to the Competition Tribunal directly (Competition Bureau guide to the June 2024 amendments).

What the rules say in the United States

The FTC announced its Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials on 14 August 2024 (FTC, 2024). It was published in the Federal Register on 22 August 2024 and took effect on 21 October 2024 (Federal Register, 2024). In brief, it prohibits:

Creating, selling or buying fake reviews and testimonials, including AI-generated ones and reviews that misrepresent the writer's experience with the product.
Giving incentives conditioned on a review expressing a particular sentiment, positive or negative.
Undisclosed reviews by a company's officers, managers or employees.
Company-controlled websites that pose as independent review sites.
Suppressing negative reviews through legal threats, intimidation or false accusations.
Buying or selling fake social media indicators, such as bot followers.

The rule lets the FTC seek civil penalties against knowing violators. Separately, the FTC's Endorsement Guides, updated in June 2023, say that people who are compensated to promote or review a product should disclose it (FTC Endorsement Guides).

A simple routine before you buy

Read the three-star reviews first. They tend to be the most specific about trade-offs.
Look beyond the brand's own website. Compare what people say in several places.
Check the company behind the product. A legal name, a mailing address and a clear returns policy are good signs. Our guide to choosing a luxury reed diffuser in Canada and our note on how to tell a good fragrance oil cover what else to look for.
Ask the brand a question. A specific, human answer is a better signal than any star rating.
Let your own nose decide. A small sampler takes reviews out of the equation entirely.
Report what looks wrong. In Canada, suspected fake reviews can be reported to the Competition Bureau; in the US, to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.

Our promise

We will never pay for or write fake reviews. Fragrance is personal, and the most reliable review you'll ever read is your own first impression in your own home. That's why we suggest starting with The Hotel Edit Discovery Set before choosing a full-size piece such as the Thé Blanc luxury reed diffuser.

And if a review anywhere leaves you with a question, ask us directly. A real person, the Curator, answers [email protected], and you can reply to any of our emails. Our contact page has the details, and you can read what makes Velour and Vellum fragrance oils different in our journal.

Quick answers

How can I tell if a home fragrance review is fake? Watch for bursts of reviews in a short period, generic praise that never describes the scent, repeated phrasing, details that don't match the product, and reviewer accounts with no other history.

Are fake reviews illegal in Canada? They can break the Competition Act's deceptive marketing provisions, which cover false or misleading representations and testimonials, and the Competition Bureau has warned businesses they can be liable for undisclosed employee reviews.

What does the FTC rule on fake reviews say? In effect since 21 October 2024, it bans fake and AI-generated reviews, sentiment-conditioned incentives, undisclosed insider reviews, fake "independent" review sites, review suppression and fake social media indicators.

Are incentivized reviews always fake? No, but they should be clearly disclosed, and US rules forbid incentives conditioned on a positive or negative review. Weigh them as context.

Will Velour and Vellum ever pay for or write fake reviews? No. We will never pay for or write fake reviews, and anyone can ask the Curator a question directly at [email protected].

Explore: the Scaldera Arch · Shop the collection · Take the Scent Quiz · Membership · Refill subscription